This event has already taken place.

Host: Intelligence Squared
Location: Cadogan Hall 5 Sloane Terrace, London, SW1X 9DQ
Speaker: James Shapiro Nigel Smith

Following the spectacular success of  ‘Jane Austen vs Emily Brontë’ debate in February, this is the second in a new strand of literary combat events.
Nearly four centuries after his death, no writer has come close to matching Shakespeare’s understanding of the world – or his gift for dramatic poetry. It’s not just kings and queens that he captured so uniquely in his transcendent verse. Shakespeare analysed the human condition, not just for Elizabethan England, but throughout the world and for eternity. Britain may not have matched the Continent for music or art but when it comes to literature, Shakespeare sees off all international rivals, whether it’s in the spheres of comedy, tragedy or the sonnet. Even today you and I quote Shakespeare without knowing it: if you act more in sorrow than in anger, if you vanish into thin air or have ever been tongue-tied, hoodwinked or slept not one wink, you’re speaking the Bard’s English.
Milton, say his fans, works on an altogether different, higher plane. In Paradise Lost – the best poem ever written in English – Milton moved beyond the literary to address political, philosophical and religious questions in a way that still resounds strongly today. In his complex, intellectual poetry he drilled down deep into the eternal truths and sought to embody new scientific discovery in his work.
His engagement with the issues of the day – with the nature of knowledge, slavery, free will, love and creation – was unparalleled. Despite complete blindness in middle age, he was the English republic’s best known, most fervent apologist, and a key civil servant for Oliver Cromwell. In his other works, notably in Areopagitica, his attack on censorship, he showed himself as much a master of prose as poetry. He defines not only his age, but our own.
To help you decide who should be crowned king of English letters two expert advocates will make the case for each writer, and they will be calling on a cast of leading actors to illustrate their arguments with readings from the works.

Advocate for Shakespeare

James Shapiro
Professor of English at Columbia University and author of 1599: A Year in the Life of William Shakespeare

Advocate for Milton

Nigel Smith Professor of Ancient and Modern Literature at Princeton University and author of Is Milton better than Shakespeare?

Erica Wagner
Former literary editor of the Times. She is Eccles British Library Writer in Residence 2014 and a judge of this year’s Man Booker Prize


Harriet Walter
Actress highly acclaimed for her work on stage, screen and television. Of her many roles with the Royal Shakespeare Company where she is an Associate Artist, the most recent have been Cleopatra in Antony and Cleopatra alongside Patrick Stewart, Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing and Lady Macbeth opposite Anthony Sher

Sam West
Actor and director who has played the title roles in the Royal Shakespeare Company’s Richard II and Hamlet. He has written essays on both plays for the Cambridge University Press and on “Shakespeare and Love” for BBC Radio 3

Remaining actors to be announced.

All speakers are subject to change.

More Information

Latest News & Events